home
reviews
essays
search

Reviews

The Other

(L'Autre, Bernard Giraudeau, France/Italy, 1990)


   


The artistic impulse behind this film may have been to marry Ernest Hemingway and Werner Herzog – an ungodly union if there ever was one.

A wheezing old gasbag (Francisco Rabal) crouches over the ruins of an earthquake in the middle of a barren Greek landscape, desperately trying to make contact with the person he knows is still alive under the rubble.

The old man raises his weary head to announce: "He said one word: I."

Kiarostami's Life and Nothing More ... (1992) it ain't.

It is a purely dreadful, hopelessly literary film, marked by director Giraudeau's fatal decision to let Rabal emote histrionically in painfully long-held shots.

© Adrian Martin January 1993


Film Critic: Adrian Martin
home    reviews    essays    search