home
reviews
essays
search

Reviews

Rosemary’s Baby

(Roman Polanski, USA, 1968)


 


Shortly after the release of Rosemary's Baby, Roman Polanski breezily commented: “Characters and utmost fear are the most important thing in cinema”. He modestly added that his own work was “real cinema, done for cinema … well in advance of anything that has been done in the semantics of cinema”.

 

Polanski was a confident, rising star in those days. He was considered an iconoclast and a modernist in the tradition of Luis Buñuel. Today, when we watch his best films from the vantage point of the 21st century (setting aside the personal controversy angle), we are likely to value him for a more forgotten, old-fashioned quality: his superb craftsmanship as a storyteller and stylist.

 

Rosemary's Baby, cleverly adapted (by Polanski himself) from Ira Levin’s best-seller, is a tale of Satanism and female paranoia set in a deceptively serene Old World apartment in New York. Rosemary (Mia Farrow) speaks with the high-pitched voice of a child and waddles around like a thin, furry, uncoordinated duckling. Her husband, Guy (John Cassavetes), is a self-absorbed actor whose mood gradually changes from scatty to menacing.

 

“Ro” has good reason to feel menaced. The dotty old couple in the next apartment, the Castevets (Ruth Gordon and Sidney Blackmer), seem to regularly lead a bunch of their cronies in spooky, mystical chants. Friends and acquaintances of the young newly-weds are found dead in mysterious circumstances. And once Rosemary falls pregnant, she is besieged by shocking nightmares, and then subtly coerced into a health program that makes her look abnormally sick.

 

Polanski's command of detail, on all levels, is incomparable. Everything is unsettling in an odd, uncanny way: the unnaturally bright colours of Rosemary's apartment, the slightly constrictive or distant camera angles, the vocal patter of everyday banalities — not to mention the fairytale-like score of his favourite composer, Krzysztof Komeda (1931-1969). Polanski's often unusual casting decisions, and his feeling for a modern comedy of urban manners, are constantly satisfying – Gordon, Cassavetes and a cameo from Charles Grodin are especially, darkly pleasurable.

 

Rosemary's Baby has stood the test of time. Some less impressed critics of the period, including Polanski’s early structuralist exegete Pascal Kané [1946-2020] at Cahiers du cinéma, found the ambiguous probing of paranoia and sexual malaise – explored so intensely in Repulsion (1965) and Cul-de-Sac (1966) – mainly to be a matter of clever patterning at the surface level of plot intrigue. Its fascination (so this argument goes) functions on a formalistic plane detached from the workings of character and theme. Others claim that, in its narrative-adaptation craft, it tends to drag in its middle section, beating time as it builds up to the genuinely disquieting finale.

 

It’s hard, today, to credit these gripes with much insight. However you slice it, Rosemary’s Baby is a terrific exercise from one of cinema's most astute artists. It marked Polanksi’s triumphant gear-change from modernist, European modes to crafty, American-style storytelling, and it clinched his status as the internationalist filmmaker par excellence.

 

In the horror genre, it stands between Alfred Hitchcock’s Psycho (1960) – Polanski regularly rejected in interviews any Hitchcockian influence – and William Friedkin’s The Exorcist (1973), as an ingenious, perfectly formed spin on Gothic nightmares of sexuality and family.

 

Postscript: In late 2016, Cristina Álvarez López and I were commissioned by curator Roberta Ciabarra of the Australian Centre for the Moving Image – today officially known only as ACMI – to make an audiovisual essay accompanying a select Polanski retrospective; just a year later, this program of events might have had a tough time getting the institutional green light. Our 16-and-a-half-minute Roman Polanski: A Cinema of Invasion can be viewed here.

MORE Polanski: Chinatown, Death and the Maiden, The Fat and the Lean, The Fearless Vampire Killers, Frantic, The Ninth Gate, The Pianist, The Tenant, Tess, Two Men and a Wardrobe, Knife in the Water

© Adrian Martin December 1997 / April 2001


Film Critic: Adrian Martin
home    reviews    essays    search